On our fifth nostalgia journey, Justin and Stephen kiki about new releases from Lady Gaga, Indigo Girls, and the Dixie Chicks. Justin also shares his thoughts on the new Broadway re-imagining of West Side Story.This week’s "slice" of nostalgia is entirely focused on Columbia House. We discuss the "12 For A Penny" negative option scheme, then make 12 "penny picks" of our own, including: the FUNNY GIRL Original Cast Recording, Natalie Cole's UNFORGETTABLE...WITH LOVE, En Vogue's FUNKY DIVAS, R.E.M.'s OUT OF TIME, Gloria Estefan's HOLD ME, THRILL ME, KISS ME, Boy George & Culture Club's AT WORST...THE BEST OF, Tom Petty's WILDFLOWERS, TLC's CRAZYSEXYCOOL, the CLUELESS Original Motion Picture Soundtrack, Taylor Dayne's GREATEST HITS, The Fugees' THE SCORE, and P!nk's CAN'T TAKE ME HOME. We also discuss our favorite "Selections of the Month," plus the albums we sent back.To reminisce along with us and join the conversation, follow us on Instagram @forthenostalgia.