Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
16:01
Trees caught everyone's attention at their
16:03
table and others nearby. She
16:05
looks around the room in feigned astonishment.
16:08
New Jersey! Can
16:10
you imagine? The
16:12
editor of Vogue is from New
16:14
Jersey. Mirabella feels
16:17
as if her face is on fire. She
16:20
thinks about how someone told her that
16:22
Warhol said Vogue promoted her because they
16:24
want to go middle class. The
16:27
East Coast elite looked down on
16:29
Mirabella's middle class roots. But
16:31
indeed, that's exactly why she was
16:33
chosen as the new editor-in-chief. She's
16:37
determined to remake Vogue for 9-5 working
16:40
women who happily buy American sportswear.
16:43
Her redesign features articles from feminists
16:45
like Gloria Steinem. It
16:48
also features less coverage of high
16:50
society New York parties and
16:52
more office appropriate wearable affordable
16:54
fashions. And
16:56
it's a home run. By
16:59
the end of the decade, Vogue's circulation more
17:01
than doubled. And gross revenue nearly
17:03
triples from $9 million in 1973 to $27 million by 1980. But
17:11
designers like Oster de la Renta
17:13
complained that Mirabella's fashion is boring.
17:16
And Vogue still hasn't caught up
17:18
with Cosmopolitan's massive readership of over
17:21
$1.7 million. If
17:24
Mirabella doesn't get with the razzle dazzle
17:26
and conspicuous consumption of the 1980s, Cosmo
17:30
will push pedestrian Vogue right
17:32
off the catwalk. For
17:35
good. We
17:39
spend a lot of our lives at work. It's
17:41
time to find ways to enjoy it. Canva
17:44
makes work more visual, more productive and
17:46
dare we say it, more fun. With
17:49
Canva you can design captivating presentations,
17:51
docs, whiteboards and videos. Wow your
17:53
audience and achieve your goals whatever
17:56
department you work in. Canva
17:58
makes you and your work more creative. look
18:00
great, no design experience needed. You'll
18:02
love what you can easily design
18:05
with Canva, and so will everyone
18:07
else. Love your
18:09
work at canva.com. Every
18:11
shelter pet deserves a second chance, and
18:14
you're making it possible for thousands of
18:16
them every day because when you feed
18:18
your pet hills, you help feed
18:20
a shelter pet, which makes them healthy,
18:22
happy, and more adoptable, changing
18:25
their life forever so they can change
18:27
yours. Over 14 million
18:29
shelter pets fed and adopted. Science
18:31
did that. Visit
18:34
hillspet.com/podcast to learn
18:36
more. It's
18:50
a sweltering afternoon in August 1983
18:52
in Midtown. Vogue editorial
18:55
director Alex Lieberman sits at his usual table
18:57
in the grill room of the Four Seasons
18:59
restaurant. He's a spry 70 years old, his
19:02
once dark hair and mustache now white.
19:05
He turns to his lunch date,
19:07
New York Magazine's fashion editor, 33-year-old
19:09
Anna Wintour. Miss Wintour,
19:12
I thoroughly enjoyed your photo spread
19:14
in the current issue. What a
19:16
great idea to invite artists to
19:18
create paintings inspired by the fall
19:20
collections. Oh, fabulous work.
19:23
You know, it reminded me of the kind
19:25
of pieces we used to feature in Vogue
19:27
when we had geniuses like Salvador Dali guest
19:29
edit issues. Ah, you
19:32
know, the magazine felt like a trip
19:34
to a world-class museum back then. Wintour
19:37
picks at her stake with her
19:39
fork. She's decided not to wear
19:41
her trademark oversized sunglasses for this
19:43
all-important first lunch meeting with the
19:45
man known as the creative force
19:48
behind Vogue. She's on her best
19:50
behavior too. Before she landed
19:52
the job at New York Mag, she'd
19:54
been fired by Harper's Bazaar for
19:56
being too headstrong, sexy and fashion
19:58
forward. If she blows
20:00
this opportunity with one of the most
20:02
powerful men at Conde Nast, her
20:05
career could be over. She
20:07
ducks her head and looks up at Lieberman from
20:09
under her long bangs. Thank you.
20:13
Lieberman smiles at the seemingly shy younger
20:15
woman in her red Dior suit with
20:17
the trendy large shoulder pads. I'd
20:19
like to see more of that kind of riding at our
20:21
shop. Have you ever
20:23
considered working for Vogue? Winter
20:26
puts down her fork. She's
20:28
got a hunch Lieberman will like her
20:30
dishy story about Vogue's current editor-in-chief. Actually
20:34
Mr. Lieberman I met with Grace Mirabella two
20:36
years ago, before I went to New York mag. I
20:39
think she found me a bit too... too
20:41
direct for her taste. Lieberman
20:44
picks up his glass of scotch and leans back
20:47
in his chair. He's intrigued.
20:50
Mirabella is as straightforward as a glass of milk.
20:53
In fact Lieberman finds her a bit
20:55
too predictable. And the soft-spoken
20:58
young Brit in front of him hardly
21:00
seems pushy. What makes
21:02
she say that? Winter pushes
21:04
away her plate. She's barely touched
21:06
her food. Grace asked me what
21:08
position I'd be interested in at Vogue, and
21:11
I told her the truth. I said I
21:13
wanted her job, of course. I
21:16
wish I'd been a fly on the wall at that meeting. I
21:19
can just imagine how that went over. But
21:23
my dear, we need some fresh
21:25
blood at the magazine. And I
21:27
think we can figure out a way to ease you
21:29
in without Grace putting up too much of a fuss.
21:32
First I want you to meet my wife at our place
21:34
in Connecticut. We can talk more then.
21:39
Lieberman is enchanted by
21:41
Winter's honesty, sense of humor, and
21:43
air of mystique. He
21:46
creates a new position at Vogue,
21:48
creative director, just for her. His
21:51
plan is to let the two women compete
21:53
against each other for the top job. Mirabella
21:56
is powerless to overrule him, and
21:59
she'll soon be blamed. blindsided by
22:01
an even bigger foreign threat. It's
22:11
1987 in Manhattan. Company
22:14
Chairman Sy Newhouse, Alex Lieberman and
22:16
Grace Mirabella sit at
22:18
the long table in the boardroom of Condé
22:20
Nast headquarters near Grand Central Station. At
22:23
60, Newhouse looks a decade younger in
22:25
his casual khakis and polo shirt. He's
22:28
still rather socially awkward, but
22:31
he has the self-assurance of a man who
22:33
knows what he's worth. Along
22:35
with his brother, he now runs an empire worth
22:38
upwards of $7.5 billion. But
22:42
today, he sounds worried. We've
22:45
got to come up with a strategy for how to
22:48
deal with Elle magazine. They
22:50
only launched the US edition last year, but
22:52
they already have over 800,000 subscribers. And
22:55
with Rupert Murdoch's billions behind them, there's no telling
22:58
how high that number will go. I
23:00
see them as a direct threat to Vogue. Elle
23:04
launched in 1945 in Paris and
23:06
grew into one of Europe's foremost
23:08
fashion publications. In 1985, French
23:11
company Hachette Publications partnered with the
23:13
media mogul Rupert Murdoch to put
23:15
out a US edition that is
23:18
now catching on like wildfire. And
23:20
every month adding more ad pages. The
23:23
magazine's aimed at younger women
23:26
with features on chunky accessories,
23:28
streetwear, and avant-garde designers. Its
23:31
circulation and revenue already eclipse
23:33
Harper's Bazaar. And now it's
23:36
catching up to Vogue. But
23:38
Mirabella is calm. Si,
23:41
we have a new record of 3,200 pages in advertising this year.
23:46
More than any other monthly magazine in the country.
23:50
Our readers are women of money and
23:52
taste. Elle caters to the
23:54
lowest common denominator, the MTV crowd. Not
23:56
on market at all. It's
23:59
trendy, cartoony, and with almost no
24:01
text and full of jokey young girl
24:03
models. It's so cute.
24:07
It'll burn bright and then fade out when
24:09
everybody gets tired of huge hoop earrings and
24:11
neon pink tutus. Newhouse
24:14
flips through some pages in a file folder in
24:16
front of him on the table. Like
24:18
the late Conde Nast, the company's founder and
24:21
namesake. He's a big believer in
24:23
research. But, Grace, this report
24:25
says that elves' readers are younger and
24:27
more affluent than the average Vogue reader.
24:30
Elves' position to siphon away our advertisers
24:33
one by one. Lieberman
24:35
has already decided. He wants
24:37
Wintour at the top of Vogue's masthead. He
24:40
sees an opportunity to pilot on Mirabella.
24:43
I'm afraid I'm with Psy. We're
24:45
vulnerable, Grace. I
24:48
know you like sophisticated minimalist fashion,
24:50
but 20-somethings are wearing bright graffiti
24:52
prints and tons of cheap necklaces
24:54
and cone-shaped bras like a what's-her-name,
24:57
that singer, Madonna. Everything's
24:59
younger and faster and flashier now. You're
25:01
aiming at women more like yourself. Stayed
25:05
career-oriented types. And I
25:07
gotta tell you, the book shows it. I
25:09
hate to say it, but it looks
25:12
tired. Mirabella
25:14
gathers her notepad and stands up.
25:17
She's clearly rattled. She
25:19
really can't stand the shallow 1980s conspicuous
25:23
consumption culture. I'm
25:25
sorry, but I have an editorial meeting. I'll
25:27
work on loosening up or lightening up or
25:29
whatevering up the pages. But Vogue isn't Vogue
25:31
if it's not classy. She
25:34
doesn't know it yet, but
25:37
Newhouse is even more enthralled with
25:39
Wintour than Lieberman. Compared
25:41
to Mirabella, the young Brits, the epitome
25:43
of everything stylish and of the moment.
25:46
And just like Psy, Wintour doesn't
25:49
do small talk. In fact,
25:51
she hardly talks at all. Meanwhile
25:54
at Cosmo, Pelle and Girly Brown barely
25:56
has time to be threatened by Elle.
26:00
are going south for other reasons.
26:07
What separates the true leaders from the rest?
26:09
It's not just vision and ambition. It's
26:12
the courage to take the road less traveled.
26:15
For those with a palpable passion for
26:17
life who lead by example, there's
26:19
the Range Rover Sport. The Range
26:21
Rover Sport is a new dimension
26:23
of sporting prowess where sophisticated refinement
26:25
meets visceral power. The dynamic launch
26:27
delivers maximal torque for increased straight
26:29
line acceleration. And with rapid
26:31
DC charging and an estimated all-electric range of 48
26:33
miles, the Range
26:35
Rover Sport plug-in electric hybrid delivers
26:37
thrilling performance with an electric edge.
26:40
Build your Range Rover
26:43
Sport at landroverusa.com. Visit
26:45
landroverusa.com to configure your Range
26:47
Rover Sport. Explore the Range
26:49
Rover Sport at landroverusa.com. We
26:52
all dread the what's for dinner question.
26:54
I know I do. And you know
26:56
how it goes. You end up ordering
26:58
takeout. Well, if you'd rather have a
27:00
home-cooked meal without the stress of planning
27:02
ahead, I gotta tell you Home Chef
27:05
makes it really easy and saves you
27:07
money too. Whether you prefer classic meal
27:09
kits with pre-portioned ingredients, oven-ready kits or
27:11
quick microwave meals, Home Chef has you
27:13
and the entire family covered for delicious
27:15
meals without all the hassle. We
27:17
love the jalapeno popper chicken with zucchini
27:19
and corn. Mwah! Chef's
27:22
Kiss. Never in freshness. And have I
27:24
mentioned the perfect price? Well, it gets
27:26
even better. For a limited time, Home
27:28
Chef is offering Business Wars listeners 18
27:32
free meals plus free
27:34
dessert for life and
27:36
of course free shipping
27:38
on your first box.
27:40
Go to homechef.com/BW. That's
27:42
homechef.com/BW for 18 free
27:45
meals and free dessert for life. Yes,
27:47
you heard that right. homechef.com/BW.
27:49
Must be an active subscriber
27:51
to receive free dessert. It's
27:57
a frigid, gray morning in January 1988 in mid-town.
32:00
I have no idea, no idea at all. I'll call you
32:02
back as soon as I know anything. In
32:05
a daze, she stumbles into Alex
32:08
Lieberman's office. He's her direct
32:10
boss at Vogue, but also a close friend.
32:13
She and her husband have often spent time with
32:15
the Liebermans at their home in Connecticut and visited
32:17
them in Europe on summer vacations. He's
32:20
sitting at his desk, doing nothing, as if
32:22
he was waiting for her. Grace,
32:25
I know why you're here, and
32:27
I'm afraid it's true. I'm
32:29
sorry, I tried to stop it, but I'm
32:32
just too old. Mirabella points
32:34
a shaky finger at him. What's
32:36
that supposed to mean? Don't go
32:38
hiding behind your age or mine either.
32:40
I'm only 59, I don't
32:42
deserve this. When I started
32:45
here, our ad pages were in the toilet.
32:47
Now they're worth 80 million a year.
32:49
El doesn't clear half that. And
32:52
you don't even have the courtesy to tell me to my face? Lieberman
32:55
shrugs. It wasn't my idea.
32:57
I gotta
32:59
tell you, I had nothing to do with it. And to
33:01
be fair, I warned you that
33:04
your endless covers of close-ups of models with
33:06
perfect blush and perfect hair were just too
33:08
predictable, and that you should have
33:10
cultivated more of a relationship with Psy, but
33:13
you avoided him. Anyway,
33:17
you should go talk to him now. Mirabella
33:20
turns on her heel and numbly rides
33:22
the elevator back to her floor. She
33:25
knows talking to Psy will do no good.
33:28
She's never had any rapport with him. And
33:31
he's famous for avoiding confrontations, too.
33:34
He makes other people do his dirty work. And
33:37
everyone at the magazine knows the tragic story of
33:39
a woman who worked at Vogue for more than
33:41
40 years. She found
33:44
out she was fired when she walked into her
33:46
empty office one day to find it empty. Overnight,
33:49
movers had packed it up and put all her
33:51
things in storage. Not long
33:53
after, she jumped out the window of her studio apartment to
33:55
her death. And now, despite having a lot of fun, I'm
33:57
not going to be able to tell you what happened. having
34:00
tripled circulation and gross revenues during her
34:02
17 years at the top of the
34:04
masthead. Mirabella is out,
34:07
and Wintour, the quiet young
34:10
Brit in Chanel suits, has
34:12
finally got her dream job. November
34:22
1988. A printing
34:24
supervisor stands in the middle of the factory floor
34:26
and examines the cover of the November issue of
34:28
Vogue. It's hot off the press. He's
34:31
been in charge of the Vogue account for
34:33
years now, but this cover looks like nothing
34:35
he's ever seen. It resembles
34:38
something his teenage daughter might read,
34:40
like 17. He
34:44
weaves his way through the plant to his
34:46
cramped office in the back, picks up the
34:48
phone and keys in the number for Vogue's
34:51
production manager. Hey Joe, what's up? Everything okay
34:53
with the print? I'm
34:55
not sure. I'm calling to check we got the right
34:57
cover. It looks like a mistake. I'm
35:00
afraid we screwed up. It's so, well,
35:04
not Vogue. The
35:07
cover photo shows a young woman wearing a
35:10
$10,000 black silk Christiane Lacroix
35:12
sweater emblazoned with a large
35:14
brightly colored bejeweled cross and
35:17
a pair of low-slung gas jeans. She
35:20
has wind-tossed messy hair, a toothy grin
35:22
and a bare midriff. It
35:24
looks like a candid shot snapped on a city
35:27
street. Headlines including men
35:29
the new himbos and fashion,
35:31
hope but not haughty, surround her
35:34
in a blizzard of bold fuchsia
35:36
print. It's Anna
35:38
Wintour's debut issue. The
35:40
high-low mix of designer fashion with
35:43
mall brand denim and
35:45
the eye-catchingly busy graphics could
35:47
not be more different from Mirabella's
35:50
spare close-ups of studio models with
35:52
every hair shellacked into place. And
35:55
the new design is a warning shot
35:57
across Elle magazine's bow. it
36:00
creates massive buzz. Cy
36:03
Newhouse sends Anna a note that reads,
36:06
You knocked it out of the park, Anna.
36:08
I'm so proud. Winter
36:11
takes full advantage of Newhouse's
36:13
goodwill to ditch staffers and
36:15
photographers she considers out of
36:17
fashion, including persuading him
36:19
to spend nearly half a million dollars
36:22
to buy out the remainder of Richard
36:24
Avedon's contract. And she
36:27
doubles down on youth and trendiness with
36:29
a cover shoot featuring Madonna. It's
36:32
a risky move in an age when
36:34
fashion magazines rely on models rather than
36:36
celebrities. Harper's Bazaar
36:38
looks more dated than ever in
36:41
third place behind newcomer Elle and
36:43
a resurging Vogue. But
36:45
they're also betting on a Brit to
36:47
restore them to their former
36:49
glory. It's
36:57
1992 in the Hamptons. Harper's
37:00
Bazaar new editor-in-chief Liz Tilbaris
37:02
kneels on the floor of
37:04
her family's beach rental. She's
37:07
44, tall, and hardly
37:09
looks the part of a fashion diva. Her
37:11
blunt cut hair is prematurely gray and she
37:13
wears a size 14 dress, which
37:16
the British press snidely loves to point
37:18
out. The fashion industry
37:20
at large stubbornly thumbs its nose at
37:22
anyone who doesn't conform to a waif-like
37:25
silhouette. The final proofs
37:27
of Tilbaris's first issue are neatly laid out
37:29
on a grid on the terracotta tile. She
37:32
points to the cover page at the top left
37:34
and looks up at the magazine's managing editor and
37:37
art director hovering on either side of her. What
37:39
do you think? Does it work? The
37:42
cover shows supermodel Linda Evangelista
37:45
surrounded by white space. Her
37:47
black lace-clad arm is raised and
37:50
hides half her face. Her palm
37:52
playfully nudges the letter A and
37:54
the word bizarre out of kilter.
37:57
The only color is the bright red of her lipstick.
38:00
The cover line reads, Enter
38:02
the era of elegance. Tilbaris's
38:05
colleagues' eyes are red with exhaustion.
38:08
They raced here from New York as soon as the proofs
38:11
came in from the printer. They've
38:13
put in weeks of 10-hour days
38:15
assembling an all-star issue. It
38:18
features articles on multicultural education and
38:20
medicine's neglect of women, alongside
38:23
first-ever photos of model Kate Moss
38:25
in an American magazine, wearing
38:27
edgy fashions. The
38:29
graphic design of the whole issue is
38:31
an homage to Bazaar in
38:34
its arty, sophisticated, smart, post-war
38:36
heyday. A return
38:38
to the Bazaar that former editor-in-chief
38:40
Carmel Snow called a
38:42
magazine for well-dressed women with well-dressed
38:45
minds, and which ran
38:47
neck-in-neck with Vogue for decades. The
38:50
art director places her hand lightly on
38:52
Tilbaris's shoulder. Liz, I wouldn't
38:54
change a thing. It's perfect. Tilbaris's
38:59
career started at British Vogue when she
39:01
won an internship in college. She
39:04
worked there for over 20 years
39:06
and succeeded Wintour as editor-in-chief. Now,
39:10
she's taking everything she learned at Vogue and
39:13
using it against them. The
39:15
new Harper's Bazaar causes a
39:18
sensation. But Bazaar
39:20
hasn't bested their rival yet. Vogue
39:23
is back on the top of the
39:25
ad-page rankings with Harper's Bazaar in the
39:27
number two spot and Elle, which blazed
39:29
like a comet for three years and
39:31
then dragged during the 1991 economic
39:33
downturn, placing in third. But
39:37
new competition is brewing that will
39:39
change the glossy game for
39:41
good. It's
39:47
1994 in Midtown. InStyle
39:49
magazine editor-in-chief Martha Nelson sits in
39:52
her spare corner office in Time
39:54
Inc.'s headquarters across from Radio City
39:56
Music Hall. She's dressed in
39:58
a simple black t-shirt and... can't
44:00
replicate heart.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More